Culver's Cod Sandwich vs McDonald's Filet-O-Fish

McDonald's Filet-O-Fish wins — CR Score 59 (Solid) vs Culver's Cod Sandwich at CR Score 49 (Skip), from 57 and 22 ratings. Updated Nov 2026. How the score works

Rate them

Culver's Cod Sandwich

3.57 avg · 22 ratings

McDonald's Filet-O-Fish

3.35 avg · 57 ratings

Comparison

Culver's Cod SandwichStatMcDonald's Filet-O-Fish
49%CR Score59%
3.57/5Avg rating3.35/5
22Ratings57
NoLimited timeNo
600 kcalCalories380 kcal
23gProtein16g
34gFat19g
55gCarbs38g
Winner

Culver's Cod Sandwich Reviews

  • Paid survey panel

    Culver's cod sandwich is crispy and juicy.

  • Paid survey panel

    The fish in the cod sandwich was delicious and made it feel like a sandwich you could get at a non-fast dining establishment. I didn't feel like I was eating something that had been frozen and then thawed.

  • Every fish item from Culver’s is worth having. Made fresh to order so it’s always hot and crispy

McDonald's Filet-O-Fish Reviews

  • Paid survey panel

    I purchase a Filet-O-Fish combo while on vacation in Kansas last month. I requested to have my fries and fish dropped fresh and to have extra tarter sauce added to my sandwich. Whenn I received my sandwich, my fish was h…

  • Paid survey panel

    I recently had a fish filet from McDonald's and it was perfect. It's my favorite sandwich on the menu. The fried fish was cooked to a golden brown just like I like it. Also, I love the tartar sauce they use. It complemen…

  • Paid survey panel

    It tasted pretty good! The fish itself was fried well, and was very puffy. I enjoyed the bread and the pickles tastes great too. I had no problems with anything else.

The verdict

Both the Culver's Cod Sandwich and McDonald's Filet-O-Fish are popular choices in the fast-food fish sandwich category, but they cater to different preferences. The Culver's option is noted for its hand-battered cod fillet, while the Filet-O-Fish is recognized for its classic steamed bun and crispy coating.

Culver's Cod Sandwich

Pros

  • + Hand-battered cod fillet praised for quality
  • + Larger portion size compared to competitors

Cons

  • − No user reviews available to gauge popularity or satisfaction
  • − Lacks detailed nutritional information

McDonald's Filet-O-Fish

Pros

  • + Crispy coating that fans enjoy
  • + Recognizable and established option since 1962

Cons

  • − No user reviews available to gauge popularity or satisfaction
  • − Smaller portion size compared to some competitors

Which should you pick?

Pick the Culver's Cod Sandwich if…

  • • You prefer a hand-battered fish sandwich with a larger portion size
  • • You want a regional favorite known for quality

Pick the McDonald's Filet-O-Fish if…

  • • You want a classic fish sandwich with a crispy coating
  • • You prefer a well-known, recognizable fast food option

People also compared