Culver's Cod Sandwich vs McDonald's Filet-O-Fish

Comparison

Culver's Cod SandwichStatMcDonald's Filet-O-Fish
6.5CR Score6.7
4.50/5Avg rating5.00/5
1Ratings1
NoLimited timeNo
—Calories380 kcal
—Protein16g
—Fat19g
—Carbs38g
Winner

Vote

0 votes

Want to say why? (optional)

Culver's Cod Sandwich Reviews

  • zgrubz

    ★★★★

    FIRE

    Every fish item from Culver’s is worth having. Made fresh to order so it’s always hot and crispy

McDonald's Filet-O-Fish Reviews

  • Awvee Storey

    ★★★★★

    FIRE

    How doesn’t a filet-o-fish not already have a few stars already 😊

The verdict

Both the Culver's Cod Sandwich and McDonald's Filet-O-Fish are popular choices in the fast-food fish sandwich category, but they cater to different preferences. The Culver's option is noted for its hand-battered cod fillet, while the Filet-O-Fish is recognized for its classic steamed bun and crispy coating.

Culver's Cod Sandwich

Pros

  • + Hand-battered cod fillet praised for quality
  • + Larger portion size compared to competitors

Cons

  • − No user reviews available to gauge popularity or satisfaction
  • − Lacks detailed nutritional information

McDonald's Filet-O-Fish

Pros

  • + Crispy coating that fans enjoy
  • + Recognizable and established option since 1962

Cons

  • − No user reviews available to gauge popularity or satisfaction
  • − Smaller portion size compared to some competitors

Which should you pick?

Pick the Culver's Cod Sandwich if…

  • • You prefer a hand-battered fish sandwich with a larger portion size
  • • You want a regional favorite known for quality

Pick the McDonald's Filet-O-Fish if…

  • • You want a classic fish sandwich with a crispy coating
  • • You prefer a well-known, recognizable fast food option

People also compared