DQ Blizzard vs McDonald's Apple Pie

DQ Blizzard wins — CR Score 82 (Fire) vs McDonald's Apple Pie at CR Score 61 (Solid), from 100 and 195 ratings. Updated Nov 2026. How the score works

Rate them

DQ Blizzard

4.25 avg · 100 ratings

McDonald's Apple Pie

3.76 avg · 195 ratings

Winner

Comparison

DQ BlizzardStatMcDonald's Apple Pie
82%CR Score61%
4.25/5Avg rating3.76/5
100Ratings195
NoLimited timeNo
690 kcalCalories240 kcal
15gProtein2g
26gFat11g
101gCarbs35g

DQ Blizzard Reviews

  • Paid survey panel

    I love a dairy queen blizzard! The one I got was the oreo blizzard and it tasted absolutely amazing. I love just how easily it melts in your mouth and I do like how sweet it is, although the sugar is probably also very i…

  • Paid survey panel

    i got a reese's blizzard from DQ on my way home after a nice dinner. i needed something sweet to end the night. it was well mixed, the ice cream nice and soft as always, just the way i like it. it was rich and thick and …

  • Paid survey panel

    The blizzard is a concoction of ice cream and mix ins that is blended together into a delicious sweet treat. I personally like the combination of chocolate and strawberries in mine. It is served with a spoon and famously…

McDonald's Apple Pie Reviews

  • Paid survey panel

    The crust was super crispy and flaky and the cinnamon apples inside were really good.My only complain is that its kind of small for the price now, i probably wouldn`t get it every time but when that craving hits its a so…

  • Paid survey panel

    This was the worst part of the meal. It was extremely cold, like it was gotten right out of the fridge. While the taste was still there, it being cold is just not the expectation when you order fast food. I heated it up …

  • Paid survey panel

    The baked apple pies are always a good snack to have, but nothing beats the fried apple pies of years gone by. The baked pies aren't always as hot as they should be, and sometimes there is more filling than actually appl…

The verdict

Both desserts have their merits, but the choice depends on what you're looking for. Reviewers rate the DQ Blizzard highly for its rich flavors and thick texture, while the McDonald's Apple Pie is praised for its affordability and classic appeal.

DQ Blizzard

Pros

  • + Rich flavors with various mix-ins — reviewers appreciate the customization options.
  • + Thick texture — users highlight the upside-down serving as a testament to its density.

Cons

  • − Higher calorie count — at 690 kcal, it's not the lightest dessert option.
  • − Limited reviews — only one user review available, making it harder to gauge overall satisfaction.

McDonald's Apple Pie

Pros

  • + Affordable — users note it as one of the cheapest desserts available.
  • + Classic taste — many fans consider it a staple item on the McDonald's menu.

Cons

  • − Lower average rating — while still popular, it has a slightly lower average rating than the Blizzard.
  • − No recent user reviews available — lacks current feedback to assess quality.

Which should you pick?

Pick the DQ Blizzard if…

  • • You want a rich, customizable dessert — reviewers appreciate the variety of mix-ins.
  • • You prefer a thicker dessert experience — users note the Blizzard's density.

Pick the McDonald's Apple Pie if…

  • • You want a classic, affordable dessert option — users highlight its low price.
  • • You prefer a lighter dessert — the Apple Pie has only 240 kcal.

People also compared