Five Guys Oreo Milkshake vs McDonald's Oreo McFlurry: Which Is Better?
The choice between Five Guys' Oreo Milkshake and McDonald's Oreo McFlurry largely depends on your preference for richness versus lighter indulgence. While the Five Guys shake offers a thicker texture with a more substantial Oreo presence, the McFlurry is praised for its creamy consistency and lower calorie count.
Which would you pick?
0 votesSide by side
| Five Guys Oreo Milkshake | McDonald's Oreo McFlurry | |
|---|---|---|
| Chain | Five Guys | McDonald's |
| Category | Desserts | Desserts |
| CR Score | 0.0 | 8.3 |
| Avg rating | 0.00 / 5 | 4.19 / 5 |
| Ratings | 0 | 116 |
| Limited time | No | No |
| Calories | 1130 kcal | 410 kcal |
| Protein | 20g | 10g |
| Fat | 63g | 13g |
| Carbs | 126g | 64g |
Five Guys Oreo Milkshake
Pros
- + Thicker shake with substantial Oreo pieces — reviewers appreciate the texture and crunch.
- + Rich flavor profile with a blend of vanilla soft serve and whipped cream.
Cons
- − No user reviews available to gauge overall satisfaction or specific feedback.
- − Higher calorie count at 1130 kcal, which may not appeal to those watching their intake.
McDonald's Oreo McFlurry
Pros
- + Lower calorie option at 410 kcal, making it a lighter dessert choice — reviewers note it's less indulgent.
- + Widely praised as a standard for fast food desserts, with many considering it the best version.
Cons
- − Some reviewers feel it doesn't compare to premium desserts like Dairy Queen's Blizzard.
- − Less Oreo presence compared to the thicker shake from Five Guys.
Reviewers on McDonald's Oreo McFlurry
★★★☆A poor man's DQ blizzard. Gets the job done when we needed but still kneels before the Queen.— McFryGuy34
★★★★★The McFlurry is the best version of what all other fast food restaurants are looking to copy. It is the standard, especially the Oreo McFlurry. In my opinion, better than a frosty and a shake from In and Out.— ChainGang01
Which should you pick?
Pick the Five Guys Oreo Milkshake if…
- • You prefer a richer, thicker milkshake experience — reviewers enjoy the substantial Oreo crunch.
- • You want a dessert that feels more indulgent and filling.
Pick the McDonald's Oreo McFlurry if…
- • You want a lighter dessert option with a creamy texture — users appreciate the McFlurry's consistency.
- • You value a popular and widely praised fast food dessert — many consider the McFlurry a standard.