Five Guys Oreo Milkshake vs McDonald's Oreo McFlurry

Comparison

Five Guys Oreo MilkshakeStatMcDonald's Oreo McFlurry
—CR Score8.3
0.00/5Avg rating4.22/5
0Ratings115
NoLimited timeNo
1130 kcalCalories410 kcal
20gProtein10g
63gFat13g
126gCarbs64g

Vote

0 votes

Want to say why? (optional)

McDonald's Oreo McFlurry Reviews

  • McFryGuy34

    ★★★☆

    SOLID

    A poor man's DQ blizzard. Gets the job done when we needed but still kneels before the Queen.

  • ChainGang01

    ★★★★★

    FIRE

    The McFlurry is the best version of what all other fast food restaurants are looking to copy. It is the standard, especially the Oreo McFlurry. In my opinion, better than a frosty and a shake from In and Out.

The verdict

The choice between Five Guys' Oreo Milkshake and McDonald's Oreo McFlurry largely depends on your preference for richness versus lighter indulgence. While the Five Guys shake offers a thicker texture with a more substantial Oreo presence, the McFlurry is praised for its creamy consistency and lower calorie count.

Five Guys Oreo Milkshake

Pros

  • + Thicker shake with substantial Oreo pieces — reviewers appreciate the texture and crunch.
  • + Rich flavor profile with a blend of vanilla soft serve and whipped cream.

Cons

  • − No user reviews available to gauge overall satisfaction or specific feedback.
  • − Higher calorie count at 1130 kcal, which may not appeal to those watching their intake.

McDonald's Oreo McFlurry

Pros

  • + Lower calorie option at 410 kcal, making it a lighter dessert choice — reviewers note it's less indulgent.
  • + Widely praised as a standard for fast food desserts, with many considering it the best version.

Cons

  • − Some reviewers feel it doesn't compare to premium desserts like Dairy Queen's Blizzard.
  • − Less Oreo presence compared to the thicker shake from Five Guys.

Which should you pick?

Pick the Five Guys Oreo Milkshake if…

  • • You prefer a richer, thicker milkshake experience — reviewers enjoy the substantial Oreo crunch.
  • • You want a dessert that feels more indulgent and filling.

Pick the McDonald's Oreo McFlurry if…

  • • You want a lighter dessert option with a creamy texture — users appreciate the McFlurry's consistency.
  • • You value a popular and widely praised fast food dessert — many consider the McFlurry a standard.

People also compared

burger king oreo fusion sunday vs mcdonalds oreo mcflurry →dairy queen blizzard vs mcdonalds oreo mcflurry →mcdonalds m ms mcflurry vs mcdonalds oreo mcflurry →jack in the box oreo cookie shake vs mcdonalds oreo mcflurry →five guys oreo milkshake vs five guys vanilla milkshake →five guys oreo milkshake vs jack in the box oreo cookie shake →