ChainReaction

Sonic All-American Smasher vs In-N-Out Double-Double — Animal Style: Which Is Better?

Both the Sonic All-American Smasher and In-N-Out's Animal Style Double-Double offer unique takes on the classic burger experience, but they cater to different preferences. Sonic features a crispy-edged smashed patty, while In-N-Out's version emphasizes mustard-grilled patties and a secret menu appeal.

Sonic All-American Smasher
A
Sonic Drive-InSonic Drive-In

Sonic All-American Smasher

—
Rate it
In-N-Out Double-Double — Animal Style
B
In-N-OutIn-N-Out

In-N-Out Double-Double — Animal Style

—
Rate it

Which would you pick?

0 votes

Side by side

Sonic All-American Smasher In-N-Out Double-Double — Animal Style
ChainSonic Drive-InIn-N-Out
CategoryBurgersBurgers
CR Score0.00.0
Avg rating0.00 / 50.00 / 5
Ratings00
Limited timeNoNo
Calories610 kcal670 kcal
Protein35g37g
Fat37g41g
Carbs32g39g

Sonic All-American Smasher

Pros

  • + Crispy-edged beef patty praised for its texture
  • + Lower calorie count at 610 kcal compared to In-N-Out

Cons

  • − No user reviews available to gauge overall satisfaction
  • − Less known compared to In-N-Out's iconic status

In-N-Out Double-Double — Animal Style

Pros

  • + Highly regarded for its flavor and customization options
  • + Animal Style adds grilled onions and extra spread for richness

Cons

  • − Higher calorie count at 670 kcal
  • − Potentially more expensive depending on location

Which should you pick?

Pick the Sonic All-American Smasher if…

  • • You prefer a lower calorie option with a crispy texture
  • • You want to try something new from Sonic

Pick the In-N-Out Double-Double — Animal Style if…

  • • You are a fan of secret menu items and customization
  • • You enjoy a richer flavor profile with grilled onions and extra spread

People also compared

in n out double double animal style vs whataburger patty meltarbys burger king cheeseburger vs in n out double double animal stylefive guys cheeseburger vs in n out double double animal stylein n out double double animal style vs wendys friesin n out double double animal style vs whataburger whataburgerin n out double double animal style vs whataburger double meat whataburger