Consider me a less is usually more person as it pertains to anything between two buns. This sandwich is the perfect example of just too much meat to distract from things like the fresh bread. Skip it and get the Vito.
Jimmy John's #9 Italian Night Club
Jimmy John'sSubs & Sandwiches
Jimmy John's Italian Night Club stacks Genoa salami, capicola, smoked ham, and provolone with lettuce, tomato, onion, mayo, and Italian dressing on French bread. Jimmy John's most popular sub, it competes with Subway's Spicy Italian and Jersey Mike's Italian as the best fast food Italian sub.
CR Score is the average of 1 user rating on a 1–10 scale. Updated May 1, 2026.
Similar Subs & Sandwiches items
Head-to-head
Compare this item against any other. First-time comparisons take a few seconds to generate.