SOLIDSubway Italian BMT
Subs & Sandwiches#0090 Overall

Subway's Italian BMT is stacked with Genoa salami, spicy pepperoni, and Black Forest ham on freshly baked bread with your choice of toppings and sauces. It's Subway's take on a classic Italian deli sub and one of their most popular menu items, often compared to Jersey Mike's and Jimmy John's Italian subs.

Subway Italian BMT

Subway
71%

Subway Italian BMT — CR Score 71 (Solid). 32 of 45 ratings were 3.5 stars or higher. Updated Nov 2026. How the score works

Rate it

Tap a star to add a comment or photo

Compare

Put this item head-to-head with any other. First-time comparisons take a few seconds to generate.

Reviews (8)

P
Paid survey panel

It’s the subway Italian BMT can come in either a six or 12 inch. It has pepperoni, salami and ham and usually it comes with provolone cheese and then whatever toppings that you like when I get it I get it with pepperoni, salami, ham, pepper, jack, cheese, lettuce, spinach, green peppers, onions, light, black, olives, and mayo, and their sweet onion sauce. I also have them toasted like how crispy it gets. I would not change too much about it. I usually get it with Italian cheese bread.

P
Paid survey panel

The flavor was all wrong and the meat didn't taste fresh. The sub fell apart as I was tryign to eat it.

P
Paid survey panel

The biggest issue was the price. It felt way too expensive for what I got, especially since the six-inch and footlong sandwiches seem like they've gotten smaller over the years. While ordering, some of the ingredients behind the counter looked old and not very crisp, which made the sandwich not seem as fresh. The sauce containers were nearly empty, and the employee ended up burning my bread a little. I think other places offer better value, more consistent quality, and similar health benefits for a lower price.

P
Paid survey panel

The Subway Italian BMT stands out because of the spicy meats that give the sandwich some extra heat without being too spicy.

P
Paid survey panel

The Italian BMT at Subway is the only sub I order, plus my preferred toppings and bread. I like Italian subs in general, and Subway's ingredients are pretty tasty.

NutritionAs sold
Calories
590 kcal
Protein
26g
Fat
35g
Carbs
44g

Similar Subs & Sandwiches items

Jimmy John's The J.J. Gargantuan

Jimmy John's · Subs & Sandwiches

70%
Subway Meatball Marinara

Subway · Subs & Sandwiches

64%
Subway Chicken & Bacon Ranch

Subway · Subs & Sandwiches

70%
Rate it