Papa John's Fiery Buffalo Chicken Pizza features grilled chicken, onions, and buffalo sauce with a three-cheese blend on Original Hand-Tossed dough. The buffalo wing in pizza form — Papa John's answer to the wing order, with all the heat and tang on one slice. Add ranch on the side and it's the closest thing to a complete bar order you can have delivered. Nutrition based on 1 slice of large original crust pizza.