Wendy's Frosty
Wendy's
71%Rank #0090
Wendy's Frosty vs Culver's Concrete Mixer
Culver's Concrete Mixer wins — CR Score 80 (Fire) vs Wendy's Frosty at CR Score 71 (Solid), from 33 and 181 ratings. Updated Nov 2026. How the score works
Rate them
Wendy's Frosty
3.96 avg · 181 ratings
Culver's Concrete Mixer
4.12 avg · 33 ratings
Comparison
| Wendy's Frosty | Stat | Culver's Concrete Mixer |
|---|---|---|
| 71% | CR Score | 80% |
| 3.96/5 | Avg rating | 4.12/5 |
| 181 | Ratings | 33 |
| No | Limited time | No |
| 300 kcal | Calories | 820 kcal |
| 15g | Protein | 15g |
| 5g | Fat | 48g |
| 16g | Carbs | 82g |
Winner
Culver's Concrete Mixer
Culver's
80%Rank #0025
Wendy's Frosty Reviews
Chocolate !
- Paid survey panel
it's the best
- Paid survey panel
I think it's good tastes like a Frosty
Culver's Concrete Mixer Reviews
The Culver’s Concrete Mixer is everything all other chains want their version to be. It’s like a McFlurry except with Wisconsin grade and locally sourced high quality dairy. The custard is truly top notch and the fact th…
The verdict
Both the Wendy's Frosty and Culver's Concrete Mixer offer unique frozen dessert experiences, but they cater to different preferences. Reviewers appreciate the Frosty's iconic thick texture and nostalgic appeal, while the Concrete Mixer is praised for its rich custard base and customizable mix-ins.
Wendy's Frosty
Pros
- + Iconic dessert with a nostalgic appeal — reviewers note it's a classic treat they grew up with.
- + Thick and creamy texture — fans mention it as a satisfying option on warm days.
Cons
- − Some users find it overly sweet — multiple reviewers comment on the sweetness level being too high.
- − Inconsistent availability — reviewers mention that the Frosty machine is often broken.
Culver's Concrete Mixer
Pros
- + Rich and dense texture — reviewers highlight the high-quality custard as superior to soft serve.
- + Customizable with various mix-ins — users appreciate the ability to personalize their dessert.
Cons
- − Limited user feedback — only one review is available, making it hard to gauge overall consistency.
- − Lower average rating compared to the Frosty — some may prefer a more established option.
Which should you pick?
Pick the Wendy's Frosty if…
- • You want a classic fast-food dessert experience — reviewers appreciate its nostalgic value.
- • You prefer a thicker, creamier treat — fans mention the Frosty's satisfying texture.
Pick the Culver's Concrete Mixer if…
- • You want a richer dessert with customizable options — reviewers praise the mix-ins and custard quality.
- • You enjoy trying new flavors — users note the flavor of the day adds variety.