Wendy's Frosty
Wendy's
71%Rank #0064
Wendy's Frosty vs Five Guys Chocolate Milkshake
Wendy's Frosty wins — CR Score 71 (Solid) vs Five Guys Chocolate Milkshake at CR Score 70 (Solid), from 181 and 27 ratings. Updated Oct 2026. How the score works
Rate them
Wendy's Frosty
3.96 avg · 181 ratings
Five Guys Chocolate Milkshake
3.93 avg · 27 ratings
Winner
Comparison
| Wendy's Frosty | Stat | Five Guys Chocolate Milkshake |
|---|---|---|
| 71% | CR Score | 70% |
| 3.96/5 | Avg rating | 3.93/5 |
| 181 | Ratings | 27 |
| No | Limited time | No |
| 300 kcal | Calories | 823 kcal |
| 15g | Protein | 15g |
| 5g | Fat | 36g |
| 16g | Carbs | 115g |
Five Guys Chocolate Milkshake
Five Guys
70%Rank #0072
Wendy's Frosty Reviews
Chocolate !
- Paid survey panel
it's the best
- Paid survey panel
I think it's good tastes like a Frosty
Five Guys Chocolate Milkshake Reviews
- Paid survey panel
Fice Guys Chocolate Milkshake is a 5 it is so yummy and creamy.
- Paid survey panel
I love a chocolate milkshake and 5 guys does a great one, very rich and flavorful
The verdict
The Wendy's Frosty offers a unique, thick dessert experience that many find nostalgic and satisfying, though some reviewers note it can be overly sweet. In contrast, the Five Guys Chocolate Milkshake promises a richer chocolate flavor with a creamy texture, but lacks user reviews for a more comprehensive assessment. Your choice may depend on whether you prefer a classic fast-food treat or a more indulgent shake experience.
Wendy's Frosty
Pros
- + Unique texture that is not quite ice cream or milkshake — reviewers appreciate its distinctiveness.
- + Widely loved for its nostalgic value and satisfying taste — many users mention it as a go-to dessert.
Cons
- − Some users find it overly sweet — several reviews mention it being too sweet for their taste.
- − Inconsistent availability due to machine issues — a few reviewers report that the machine is often broken.
Five Guys Chocolate Milkshake
Pros
- + Rich chocolate flavor that stands out — reviewers note the chocolate hits harder than most fast food shakes.
- + Thick and creamy texture — fans appreciate the indulgent quality of the shake.
Cons
- − No user reviews available to provide insights on taste or experience — the lack of feedback makes it hard to gauge popularity.
- − Higher calorie count compared to the Frosty — at 823 kcal, it may not be the best choice for those watching their intake.
Which should you pick?
Pick the Wendy's Frosty if…
- • You want a nostalgic dessert experience — many users mention the Frosty as a childhood favorite.
- • You prefer a lighter option — the Frosty has significantly fewer calories than the milkshake.
Pick the Five Guys Chocolate Milkshake if…
- • You seek a richer chocolate flavor — reviewers note the intensity of the chocolate in the milkshake.
- • You want a more indulgent treat — the milkshake is described as thicker and creamier.