McDonald's Quarter Pounder vs Five Guys Cheeseburger

Five Guys Cheeseburger wins — CR Score 74 (Solid) vs McDonald's Quarter Pounder at CR Score 69 (Solid), from 73 and 216 ratings. Updated Nov 2026. How the score works

Rate them

McDonald's Quarter Pounder

3.86 avg · 216 ratings

Five Guys Cheeseburger

4.07 avg · 73 ratings

Comparison

McDonald's Quarter PounderStatFive Guys Cheeseburger
69%CR Score74%
3.86/5Avg rating4.07/5
216Ratings73
NoLimited timeNo
520 kcalCalories840 kcal
30gProtein46g
26gFat50g
42gCarbs40g
Winner

McDonald's Quarter Pounder Reviews

  • Paid survey panel

    It was prepared about how it is always prepared, so it was not bad. It was actually hotter than normal. Whether that means it was fresh or under the heat lamp im not sure. But with it being hot it tasted much better than…

  • Paid survey panel

    The quarter pounder that I got came with cheese. I got it from a drive-thru. It came with pickles, diced onions, ketchup and mustard. I ordered large fries and a large milkshake on the side. The meat was cooked and juicy…

  • Paid survey panel

    McDonald's quarter pouder has always been and continues to be one of my favorite fast food treats. I always get it with a large fry and coke. McDonald's is very close to me. It's always clean and smells good. The burger …

Five Guys Cheeseburger Reviews

  • Paid survey panel

    Do not order this. The cheeseburger is like every other burger. It is a delicious burger, with bun, patties done to your order, and you can add condiments as you wish. The usual toppings are available too like tomato, on…

  • Paid survey panel

    The five guys cheese burger is always a solid choice. I like to get mine with with pickles and mushrooms. It taste great with their fries. The meat is cooked well and doesn't taste like the burger at other low quality fa…

  • Paid survey panel

    The price was absolutely outrageous. I could go to a restuarant or grill some similar tasting burgers at hone for MUCH cheaper

The verdict

The McDonald's Quarter Pounder offers a classic fast-food burger experience with a solid average rating, while the Five Guys Cheeseburger is recognized for its quality and customization, though it lacks user ratings. Depending on your preference for a traditional burger or a customizable option, your choice may vary.

McDonald's Quarter Pounder

Pros

  • + Popular choice among fast-food fans — reviewers rate it 4.11/5 on average
  • + Lower calorie count compared to Five Guys Cheeseburger — 520 kcal

Cons

  • − No recent user reviews available to gauge current sentiment
  • − Less customization compared to Five Guys

Five Guys Cheeseburger

Pros

  • + Known for high-quality ingredients — users appreciate the hand-formed patties
  • + Unlimited free toppings allow for extensive customization

Cons

  • − No user ratings available to assess popularity or satisfaction
  • − Higher calorie count at 840 kcal may be a concern for some

Which should you pick?

Pick the McDonald's Quarter Pounder if…

  • • You prefer a classic fast-food burger experience — reviewers rate it 4.11/5
  • • You want a lower-calorie option — Quarter Pounder has 520 kcal

Pick the Five Guys Cheeseburger if…

  • • You value customization — Five Guys offers unlimited toppings
  • • You prefer a larger burger with more protein — Five Guys has 46g protein

People also compared