McDonald's Big Mac
McDonald's
61%Rank #0116
McDonald's Big Mac vs Five Guys Cheeseburger
Five Guys Cheeseburger wins — CR Score 74 (Solid) vs McDonald's Big Mac at CR Score 61 (Solid), from 70 and 215 ratings. Updated Oct 2026. How the score works
Rate them
McDonald's Big Mac
3.73 avg · 215 ratings
Five Guys Cheeseburger
4.10 avg · 70 ratings
Comparison
| McDonald's Big Mac | Stat | Five Guys Cheeseburger |
|---|---|---|
| 61% | CR Score | 74% |
| 3.73/5 | Avg rating | 4.10/5 |
| 215 | Ratings | 70 |
| No | Limited time | No |
| 580 kcal | Calories | 840 kcal |
| 25g | Protein | 46g |
| 34g | Fat | 50g |
| 45g | Carbs | 40g |
Winner
Five Guys Cheeseburger
Five Guys
74%Rank #0049
McDonald's Big Mac Reviews
- Paid survey panel
The McD's Big Mac has always been my favorite fast food burger since I was a kid primarily because I love the sauce and other items it has in it.
- Paid survey panel
The McDonalds Big Mac. Because it's a microwaved heat patty with shredded lettuce, more bun, over priced and tastes awful and hey didn't use to be that way 40 years ago, but things change.
- Paid survey panel
I rated the Big Mac 5 because it's the option I probably have the most experience with, that I've always enjoyed
Five Guys Cheeseburger Reviews
- Paid survey panel
Five Guys Cheeseburger - it just stands out with its freshness and more robust flavor
- Paid survey panel
I rated the five guys cheeseburger as a 5 because it is the best fast food burger I have had. It comes the closet to something we make at home and taste fresh and real
- Paid survey panel
I named Five Guys cheeseburger because it is really good.
The verdict
The Big Mac is a classic fast food choice known for its iconic status and consistent quality, while the Five Guys Cheeseburger offers customization and a premium feel but lacks recent user feedback. If you want a reliable, well-loved burger, the Big Mac might be your best bet; if you're looking for a customizable experience, consider Five Guys despite the lack of reviews.
McDonald's Big Mac
Pros
- + Iconic and widely recognized burger — reviewers highlight its classic taste.
- + Consistent quality across locations — many users appreciate the familiar flavor.
Cons
- − Some find it overly processed compared to gourmet options.
- − Limited customization options compared to other burger chains.
Five Guys Cheeseburger
Pros
- + Unlimited free toppings allow for extensive customization — fans appreciate the variety.
- + Known for higher quality ingredients — users mention a premium feel.
Cons
- − No recent user reviews available — it's hard to gauge current satisfaction.
- − Higher price point compared to traditional fast food burgers.
Which should you pick?
Pick the McDonald's Big Mac if…
- • You want a classic fast food experience — reviewers highlight its iconic taste.
- • You prefer a burger with consistent quality across locations.
Pick the Five Guys Cheeseburger if…
- • You want a customizable burger experience — fans appreciate the unlimited toppings.
- • You prefer a premium feel with higher quality ingredients.