Five Guys
Five Guys Chocolate Milkshake vs McDonald's Quarter Pounder
Five Guys Chocolate Milkshake wins — CR Score 70 (Solid) vs McDonald's Quarter Pounder at CR Score 69 (Solid), from 27 and 216 ratings. Updated Nov 2026. How the score works
Rate them
Five Guys Chocolate Milkshake
3.93 avg · 27 ratings
McDonald's Quarter Pounder
3.86 avg · 216 ratings
Comparison
| Five Guys Chocolate Milkshake | Stat | McDonald's Quarter Pounder |
|---|---|---|
| 70% | CR Score | 69% |
| 3.93/5 | Avg rating | 3.86/5 |
| 27 | Ratings | 216 |
| No | Limited time | No |
| 823 kcal | Calories | 520 kcal |
| 15g | Protein | 30g |
| 36g | Fat | 26g |
| 115g | Carbs | 42g |
McDonald's
Five Guys Chocolate Milkshake Reviews
- Paid survey panel
Fice Guys Chocolate Milkshake is a 5 it is so yummy and creamy.
- Paid survey panel
I love a chocolate milkshake and 5 guys does a great one, very rich and flavorful
McDonald's Quarter Pounder Reviews
- Paid survey panel
It was prepared about how it is always prepared, so it was not bad. It was actually hotter than normal. Whether that means it was fresh or under the heat lamp im not sure. But with it being hot it tasted much better than…
- Paid survey panel
The quarter pounder that I got came with cheese. I got it from a drive-thru. It came with pickles, diced onions, ketchup and mustard. I ordered large fries and a large milkshake on the side. The meat was cooked and juicy…
- Paid survey panel
McDonald's quarter pouder has always been and continues to be one of my favorite fast food treats. I always get it with a large fry and coke. McDonald's is very close to me. It's always clean and smells good. The burger …
The verdict
The Five Guys Chocolate Milkshake offers a rich, creamy chocolate experience but lacks user reviews to gauge its popularity, while the McDonald's Quarter Pounder is well-reviewed and recognized for its quality and taste. If you're looking for a dessert, the milkshake might be tempting, but the Quarter Pounder is a safer bet based on user satisfaction.
Five Guys Chocolate Milkshake
Pros
- + Thick and creamy texture praised by fans of milkshakes.
- + Indulgent chocolate flavor noted by reviewers.
Cons
- − No user reviews available to assess popularity or satisfaction.
- − High calorie count may be a concern for some.
McDonald's Quarter Pounder
Pros
- + Well-reviewed for its taste and quality, with an average rating of 4.11/5.
- + Fresh beef patty cooked to order, appealing to burger fans.
Cons
- − Less indulgent than a milkshake, as it's a savory option.
- − May not satisfy those specifically seeking a dessert.
Which should you pick?
Pick the Five Guys Chocolate Milkshake if…
- • You want a rich dessert experience with a thick milkshake.
- • You're a fan of chocolate flavors in your treats.
Pick the McDonald's Quarter Pounder if…
- • You prefer a savory meal option with good user ratings.
- • You're looking for a filling burger with quality ingredients.


