ChainReaction

Jack in the Box Oreo Cookie Shake vs McDonald's Oreo McFlurry: Which Is Better?

The McDonald's Oreo McFlurry is well-regarded for its creamy texture and is often considered the standard for fast-food desserts, while the Jack in the Box Oreo Cookie Shake, despite being a flagship offering, lacks user reviews to provide insights. If you're looking for a popular and well-reviewed option, the McFlurry may be the better choice right now.

Which would you pick?

0 votes

Side by side

Jack in the Box Oreo Cookie ShakeMcDonald's Oreo McFlurry
ChainJack in the BoxMcDonald's
CategoryDessertsDesserts
CR Score0.08.3
Avg rating0.00 / 54.19 / 5
Ratings0116
Limited timeNoNo
Calories690 kcal410 kcal
Protein14g10g
Fat27g13g
Carbs99g64g

Jack in the Box Oreo Cookie Shake

Pros

  • + Thick and sweet, offering a rich cookies-and-cream flavor.
  • + Flagship dessert for Jack in the Box, indicating a strong brand emphasis.

Cons

  • No user reviews available to gauge overall satisfaction.
  • High calorie count at 690 kcal per serving.

McDonald's Oreo McFlurry

Pros

  • + Highly rated with an average score of 4.19/5 from 116 ratings.
  • + Considered the standard for fast-food desserts by many fans.

Cons

  • Some users describe it as inferior to other dessert options like DQ Blizzard.
  • Lower calorie count (410 kcal) may not satisfy those seeking a richer treat.

Reviewers on McDonald's Oreo McFlurry

★★★A poor man's DQ blizzard. Gets the job done when we needed but still kneels before the Queen. McFryGuy34
★★★★★The McFlurry is the best version of what all other fast food restaurants are looking to copy. It is the standard, especially the Oreo McFlurry. In my opinion, better than a frosty and a shake from In and Out. ChainGang01

Which should you pick?

Pick the Jack in the Box Oreo Cookie Shake if…

  • You prefer a thicker shake experience with a strong cookies-and-cream flavor.
  • You are a fan of Jack in the Box's menu offerings.

Pick the McDonald's Oreo McFlurry if…

  • You want a well-reviewed dessert with a creamy texture.
  • You prefer a lower calorie option that still delivers on taste.

People also compared