Wendy's Frosty vs Shake Shack Milkshake: Which Is Better?
The Wendy's Frosty offers a unique, thick dessert experience that many find nostalgic and satisfying, despite some complaints about sweetness and machine availability. In contrast, the Shake Shack Milkshake, while not yet rated, is noted for its premium custard base, providing a richer texture. Your choice depends on whether you prefer a classic fast-food dessert or a potentially more indulgent shake experience.
Which would you pick?
0 votesSide by side
| Wendy's Frosty | Shake Shack Milkshake | |
|---|---|---|
| Chain | Wendy's | Shake Shack |
| Category | Desserts | Desserts |
| CR Score | 8.2 | 0.0 |
| Avg rating | 4.17 / 5 | 0.00 / 5 |
| Ratings | 86 | 0 |
| Limited time | No | No |
| Calories | 300 kcal | — |
| Protein | 15g | — |
| Fat | 5g | — |
| Carbs | 16g | — |
Wendy's Frosty
Pros
- + Thick and creamy texture praised by many reviewers
- + Iconic dessert that many find nostalgic
- + Available in multiple flavors including chocolate, vanilla, and strawberry
Cons
- − Some users report that it can be too sweet
- − Inconsistent availability due to machine issues
- − Mixed reviews on flavor intensity
Shake Shack Milkshake
Pros
- + Made with real frozen custard for a richer texture
- + Hand-spun, which may appeal to those seeking a premium shake experience
- + Offers multiple flavors including seasonal options
Cons
- − No user reviews available to gauge quality or satisfaction
- − Lacks the established reputation of the Frosty
Reviewers on Wendy's Frosty
★★★★★Chocolate !— Robin mASSARO
★☆☆☆☆it's the best— roger h.
★☆☆☆☆I think it's good tastes like a Frosty— cheryl
Which should you pick?
Pick the Wendy's Frosty if…
- • You want a nostalgic classic dessert experience
- • You prefer a thick, creamy treat that many find satisfying
Pick the Shake Shack Milkshake if…
- • You are looking for a premium shake made with custard
- • You want a richer, hand-spun shake experience