FIREJimmy John's #9 Italian Night Club
Subs & Sandwiches#0031 Overall

Jimmy John's Italian Night Club stacks Genoa salami, capicola, smoked ham, and provolone with lettuce, tomato, onion, mayo, and Italian dressing on French bread. Jimmy John's most popular sub, it competes with Subway's Spicy Italian and Jersey Mike's Italian as the best fast food Italian sub.

Jimmy John's #9 Italian Night Club

Jimmy John's
79%

Jimmy John's #9 Italian Night Club — CR Score 79 (Fire). 25 of 31 ratings were 3.5 stars or higher. Updated Nov 2026. How the score works

Rate it

Tap a star to add a comment or photo

Compare

Put this item head-to-head with any other. First-time comparisons take a few seconds to generate.

Reviews (8)

P
Paid survey panel

Jimmy Johns italian night club is delicious and the sauce makes it even better.

P
Paid survey panel

The Jimmy John Italian was very good and was better than a lot of the Italian type subs I have had in the past.

P
Paid survey panel

i love jimmy johns italian club. I just love the seasonsings they put on

P
Paid survey panel

I would say it's Jimmy John's #9 Italian sub. I had heard great things from many people and had Italian subs from all sorts of places before and so I had a bit of an expectation as to what it would taste like. It wasn't bad, but it wasn't remotely as flavorful as I would have liked and I felt that the cheese and other elements really melded together and you couldn't taste them individually all that much. The bread was the highlight of the sandwich for me I think.

P
Paid survey panel

I like the Italian sandwiches from Jimmy John's. Most fast food is heavy and doesn't taste fresh, but Jimmy John's is a bit lighter and seems more fresh. The toppings and sauce they put on Jimmy John's sandwiches make them better than the heavy fried offerings at other places.

NutritionAs sold
Calories
930 kcal
Protein
48g
Fat
46g
Carbs
77g

Similar Subs & Sandwiches items

Jimmy John's The J.J. Gargantuan

Jimmy John's · Subs & Sandwiches

70%
Subway Italian BMT

Subway · Subs & Sandwiches

71%
Subway Meatball Marinara

Subway · Subs & Sandwiches

64%
Rate it