BK Whopper vs McDonald's Big Mac

Comparison

BK WhopperStatMcDonald's Big Mac
6.8CR Score8.0
3.88/5Avg rating4.02/5
4Ratings121
NoLimited timeNo
670 kcalCalories580 kcal
31gProtein25g
39gFat34g
54gCarbs45g
Winner

Vote

7 votes
57% · 443% · 3

Want to say why? (optional)

BK Whopper Reviews

  • Stephen

    ★★★★

    FIRE

    Better now than ever!

  • Burgerdude

    ★★★★☆

    SOLID

    Pretty darn delicious for the money, my go to when I’m traveling and looking for something consistent. I think the Whopper may be making a comeback!

  • ChainGang01

    ★★★☆

    SOLID

    I’ve been hearing a lot about the return of the Whopper, and I must say I was pleasantly surprised with the quality of this burger. The patty was better than what you’d see on a Big Mac, with a good flame grilled taste. …

McDonald's Big Mac Reviews

  • stephen

    ★★★★★

    FIRE

    This was incredible

The verdict

The Whopper offers a flame-grilled taste and substantial patty, appealing to those who enjoy a more grilled flavor, while the Big Mac is praised for its iconic status and consistent quality. Depending on your preference for grill marks or classic fast-food taste, each has its strengths.

BK Whopper

Pros

  • + Flame-grilled taste — reviewers mention a good flame grilled flavor
  • + Substantial patty — users appreciate the size of the patty

Cons

  • − Ratios seem slightly off — one reviewer noted the burger's proportions weren't perfect
  • − Quality may vary — one reviewer experienced it at a gas station location

McDonald's Big Mac

Pros

  • + Iconic status — many reviewers highlight its legendary status in fast food
  • + Consistent quality — users report a reliable taste across locations

Cons

  • − Higher calorie count — at 600 kcal, it's slightly more caloric than the Whopper
  • − Less grilled flavor — some reviewers may prefer the flame-grilled taste of the Whopper

Which should you pick?

Pick the BK Whopper if…

  • • You prefer a flame-grilled flavor — reviewers mention the good grilled taste
  • • You want a substantial beef patty — users appreciate the size of the Whopper's patty

Pick the McDonald's Big Mac if…

  • • You value iconic fast food — many users praise the Big Mac's legendary status
  • • Consistency matters to you — reviewers report reliable taste across locations

What voters are saying

McDonald's Big Mac

The Big Mac, ironically, is the king of fast food sandwiches. Double patty, special sauce, sesame seed bun, what's not to like?!?!— McFryGuy34

People also compared