McDonald's Big Mac
McDonald's
61%Rank #0183
McDonald's Big Mac vs Shake Shack ShackBurger
Shake Shack ShackBurger wins — CR Score 65 (Solid) vs McDonald's Big Mac at CR Score 61 (Solid), from 43 and 215 ratings. Updated Nov 2026. How the score works
Rate them
McDonald's Big Mac
3.73 avg · 215 ratings
Shake Shack ShackBurger
3.77 avg · 43 ratings
Comparison
| McDonald's Big Mac | Stat | Shake Shack ShackBurger |
|---|---|---|
| 61% | CR Score | 65% |
| 3.73/5 | Avg rating | 3.77/5 |
| 215 | Ratings | 43 |
| No | Limited time | No |
| 580 kcal | Calories | 500 kcal |
| 25g | Protein | 29g |
| 34g | Fat | 30g |
| 45g | Carbs | 26g |
Winner
Shake Shack ShackBurger
Shake Shack
65%Rank #0144
McDonald's Big Mac Reviews
- Paid survey panel
The McD's Big Mac has always been my favorite fast food burger since I was a kid primarily because I love the sauce and other items it has in it.
- Paid survey panel
The McDonalds Big Mac. Because it's a microwaved heat patty with shredded lettuce, more bun, over priced and tastes awful and hey didn't use to be that way 40 years ago, but things change.
- Paid survey panel
I rated the Big Mac 5 because it's the option I probably have the most experience with, that I've always enjoyed
Shake Shack ShackBurger Reviews
- Paid survey panel
Shake Shack Burger is done simply but really good.
- Paid survey panel
I love shake shacks burgers because they are juicy and the cheese and bacon are incredible
- Paid survey panel
Shake Shack’s Shack burger is excellent because the sauce is really good and pairs well with the cheese, which is already unique.
The verdict
The choice between the Big Mac and Shake Shack's ShackBurger largely depends on your preference for iconic fast food versus a more modern fast casual experience. Reviewers give the Big Mac a solid 4.03 average rating based on 120 reviews, highlighting its iconic status and taste, while the ShackBurger currently lacks user ratings and reviews, making it harder to assess its appeal.
McDonald's Big Mac
Pros
- + Iconic status — reviewers highlight its recognition and legacy in fast food.
- + Consistent taste — many users appreciate the familiar flavor across locations.
Cons
- − Limited recent reviews — only one recent review available, which may not reflect current quality.
- − Some may find it too classic and less innovative compared to newer options.
Shake Shack ShackBurger
Pros
- + High-quality ingredients — fans of Shake Shack often praise the use of Angus beef and non-GMO buns.
- + Modern appeal — Shake Shack is known for a more upscale fast casual dining experience.
Cons
- − No user ratings available — currently lacks feedback to gauge customer satisfaction.
- − Less iconic — may not have the same recognition as the Big Mac, making it a riskier choice for some.
Which should you pick?
Pick the McDonald's Big Mac if…
- • You want a classic fast food experience — reviewers praise the Big Mac's iconic taste.
- • You prefer a burger with a proven track record — the Big Mac has many positive reviews.
Pick the Shake Shack ShackBurger if…
- • You seek a more modern burger experience — Shake Shack is known for its fresh ingredients.
- • You want to try something new — the ShackBurger represents a different fast casual approach.