McDonald's Big Mac
McDonald's
61%Rank #0116
McDonald's Big Mac vs In-N-Out Double-Double — Animal Style
In-N-Out Double-Double — Animal Style wins — CR Score 91 (Fire) vs McDonald's Big Mac at CR Score 61 (Solid), from 26 and 215 ratings. Updated Oct 2026. How the score works
Rate them
McDonald's Big Mac
3.73 avg · 215 ratings
In-N-Out Double-Double — Animal Style
4.50 avg · 26 ratings
Comparison
| McDonald's Big Mac | Stat | In-N-Out Double-Double — Animal Style |
|---|---|---|
| 61% | CR Score | 91% |
| 3.73/5 | Avg rating | 4.50/5 |
| 215 | Ratings | 26 |
| No | Limited time | No |
| 580 kcal | Calories | 670 kcal |
| 25g | Protein | 37g |
| 34g | Fat | 41g |
| 45g | Carbs | 39g |
Winner
91%Rank #0001
McDonald's Big Mac Reviews
- Paid survey panel
The McD's Big Mac has always been my favorite fast food burger since I was a kid primarily because I love the sauce and other items it has in it.
- Paid survey panel
The McDonalds Big Mac. Because it's a microwaved heat patty with shredded lettuce, more bun, over priced and tastes awful and hey didn't use to be that way 40 years ago, but things change.
- Paid survey panel
I rated the Big Mac 5 because it's the option I probably have the most experience with, that I've always enjoyed
In-N-Out Double-Double — Animal Style Reviews
- Paid survey panel
In n out double double animal style. In n out is consistently good, I love their sauce, the flavorful patty, and generous amount of veggies.
- Paid survey panel
In and Out Double Double animal style. They are nostalgic from my youth, consistent and the price is completely reasonable for the product.
- Paid survey panel
The In-N-Out double is my favorite fast food burger ever
The verdict
The McDonald's Big Mac is a classic choice with a solid user rating, while the In-N-Out Double-Double Animal Style is a fan-favorite but lacks user reviews to gauge its reception. If you prefer a well-established burger with consistent praise, the Big Mac is a strong option; however, if you're curious about a cult favorite with a unique preparation, the Double-Double might be worth a try.
McDonald's Big Mac
Pros
- + Iconic and widely recognized burger — reviewers appreciate its classic status
- + High average user rating of 4.02/5 indicates general satisfaction
- + Contains a moderate amount of protein at 25g
Cons
- − Some may find it too standard or not adventurous enough
- − Higher fat content at 34g might not appeal to health-conscious eaters
In-N-Out Double-Double — Animal Style
Pros
- + Unique preparation with mustard-grilled patties and extra spread — fans note its distinct flavor
- + Part of In-N-Out's secret menu, which adds to its appeal for fans
Cons
- − No user reviews available to assess quality or satisfaction
- − Higher calorie count at 670 kcal and fat content at 41g may be a concern for some
Which should you pick?
Pick the McDonald's Big Mac if…
- • You want a classic burger experience — reviewers appreciate its iconic status
- • You prefer a burger with proven user satisfaction — it has a high average rating
Pick the In-N-Out Double-Double — Animal Style if…
- • You are looking for a unique flavor profile — fans highlight its special preparation
- • You want to try something associated with a popular secret menu item